Bankwest vs Bank of Melbourne: which home loan suits you?
Last reviewed
Bankwest (owned by CBA) and Bank of Melbourne (owned by Westpac) are both regional-flavoured brands sitting inside a big four banking group. Each can price and assess slightly differently to its parent, which sometimes makes one of them the better fit even when the parent bank has said no or offered a less competitive deal.
| Attribute | Bankwest | Bank of Melbourne |
|---|---|---|
| Rate positioning | Competitive variable and fixed pricing with a Western Australian heritage brand; policy and pricing set independently of CBA day-to-day, though ultimately part of the same group. | Positioned with a Victorian community heritage brand; pricing and promotions can differ from Westpac's own at any given time. |
| Offset & redraw | Offset available on packaged variable loans; redraw generally available. | Offset available on packaged variable products; redraw generally available. |
| Fees | Annual package fee structure broadly comparable to major bank packages. | Annual package fee structure broadly comparable to major bank packages. |
| Cashback / promotions | Has run its own refinance cashback offers, sometimes more aggressive than CBA's at the same time. | Has run its own refinance cashback offers, sometimes more aggressive than Westpac's at the same time. |
| Turnaround / service | Own contact centre and digital banking; smaller footprint than CBA but generally efficient. | Own branch presence concentrated in Victoria; generally efficient broker-channel service. |
| Borrowing power quirks | Uses its own serviceability settings, which can occasionally differ from CBA's parent settings and approve a file CBA declined (or vice versa). | Similarly runs its own serviceability settings distinct from Westpac's, useful when the flagship brand's calculator is unfavourable to your file. |
| Best suited to | Borrowers wanting big-four-backed security with a distinct regional brand and, sometimes, a sharper live offer. | Victorian-based or Westpac-group borrowers wanting a local brand feel with big-four backing. |
Why 'second brand' comparisons matter
Because Bankwest and Bank of Melbourne sit inside CBA's and Westpac's groups respectively but run their own credit and pricing settings, a broker will sometimes run the same application through the parent bank and its second brand to see which one comes back with a better outcome — same underlying banking group, genuinely different result.
What's actually different
- Promotional cashback and fixed-rate specials are set independently at each brand and don't always mirror the parent bank's current offer.
- Serviceability calculators, while built on similar risk principles, are maintained separately and can produce a different maximum loan amount for an identical file.
- Branch and service footprint differs — Bankwest is historically strongest in WA, Bank of Melbourne in Victoria — though both now operate more broadly.
Who should pick which
If CBA's calculator or current offer doesn't work for your file, ask a broker to check Bankwest before assuming the answer is the same across the group.
Same logic applies for Westpac and Bank of Melbourne — and St.George and BankSA are worth checking too, since all three sit under the same parent with independent settings.
A note on pricing
Indicative only — check current pricing. Rates, fees and cashback offers change frequently and vary by loan purpose, LVR and lender promotion. Nothing on this page is a quote; speak to an XLOANS broker for live pricing from both lenders.
Beyond the big four
Why people sometimes use a non-major lender
CBA, Westpac, ANZ and NAB aren't always the best fit. Non-major banks (like ING, Macquarie, AMP and Bank Australia) and non-bank lenders (like Athena, Firstmac, Resimac, La Trobe Financial and RedZed) can suit borrowers for a few reasons:
Different policy
Non-major banks and non-bank lenders often accept situations the big four decline — one year of self-employed financials, BAS or accountant-declaration income, recent job changes, or credit file issues.
Lower assessment buffers
APRA expects the banks it regulates to test your repayments at least 3% above your loan rate. Non-bank lenders aren't bound by that guidance, and some use a smaller buffer — which can mean more borrowing power.
Sharp pricing
Lenders like ING, Macquarie and Athena don't carry a big branch network, so they often compete hard on rate and fees for straightforward borrowers.
Speed and service
Smaller credit teams can mean quicker decisions and more flexibility on complex files, especially through a broker.
Unusual properties
Some specialist lenders are more comfortable with smaller units, rural blocks or mixed-use security than a major bank.
The trade-off: specialist and non-bank loans can carry higher rates or fees, and fewer branch options. A lower buffer also means less room if rates rise. An XLOANS broker can tell you whether a non-major lender genuinely helps your situation.
Ask a broker if a non-major lender suits youBook a free 15-minute chat
An XLOANS broker can pull live rates and policy for Bankwest and Bank of Melbourne (and 40+ other lenders) against your actual numbers — no cost, no obligation.
Other comparisons with these lenders
Frequently asked questions
Indicative only — check current pricing. This page is general information, not financial advice, and does not quote live rates. Lender policy, pricing and cashback offers change frequently. Speak to an XLOANS broker for advice tailored to your situation.
Not sure between Bankwest and Bank of Melbourne?
An XLOANS broker compares live rates and policy across 40+ lenders — free, in 15 minutes.
